One Thing to Say

      Life goes on.  Between episodes of grief, between tirades & protests, we still eat.  We still sleep, & do all the mundane acts of everyday life.  So yes, I have still been cooking.  And yes, I have still been writing.
      More importantly, I have been listening.
      The murders of George Floyd and Manuel Ellis have been vivid splashes of horror in an already rough point in time--but only for those who live in privilege.  For people of color, these were not sudden, shocking events: they are the other shoe that people of color perpetually wait to drop.  They expect it every day.  This time, our communities have reacted with greater volume & energy than at any other point in my life.  Those reactions have been myriad & intense.  More than ever, I see the social equivalent of Newton's Third Law: every action has an equal & opposite reaction.  So there are a lot things I could say, a lot of events on which I could comment.
      But as a white woman, born into upper-middle class privilege, I have only one thing to say:

The oppression of people of color is wrong.
The culture of violence against Black people must end.
Whether acute or systemic, racism must never be tolerated.


      Find your way to contribute to the cause.  There cannot be just one approach to finding justice, it takes many voices, many tools to dismantle the sickness of so many generations.  Take action, & stay strong.


      This is not a political blog, although I believe that any act of life can be political if approached correctly.  Next week I will return to my usual topics of writing & food.  But I will strive to give my art & the mundane actions of living meaning in these times of change.  I invite you to do the same.

There's Not Enough Fiction to Escape from this Reality

      When I woke up this morning, I kept waiting for Scorpius Malfoy to burst in and confess he'd been messing with an illegal Time Turner.*  Only there's no desperate remnants of the Order of the Phoenix living in hiding, willing to sacrifice themselves to make it all right.  A tragically significant portion of my country's population is driven by fear, hate, and ignorance.  This is the reality I live in.
      Trump declared himself a "unifier."  Just thinking about it makes my stomach turn, but in a way he was right: nothing brings people together like a common enemy.  There are a lot of people who feel that anyone who doesn't share the same skin color, or language, or religion, or way of loving is an enemy.  That's a pretty terrifying thought.

Not to mix my fantasy fiction references, but apparently Cersei was on Trump's advisory committee.
      I had decided to keep politics out of this blog.  I didn't want to estrange potential readers, agents, editors or publishers.  But what I write is inherently political, because it reflects my values.  Sometimes that may be subtle, but other times it takes front and center.  And the last thing I want to do is let my selfishness or fear steal my right to free speech.  So while this is STILL not a political blog, I am not going to shy away from sticking up for what's right.  This U.S. presidential election was a horrible blow to a lot of people around the world.  The only thing to do is pick ourselves up, find one another's hand to hold, and figure out how to fight harder.  That's what separates the Great - Mahatma Gandhi, Nelson Mandela, Malala Yousafzai - from the victims.
      By the way, I'm declaring Donald Trump's birthday as Voldemort Day.  I plan to mark it every year with a "What Would the Order of the Phoenix Do?" gathering to encourage activism.  You're invited.  Bring your ideas.


*If you don't get the reference, get off your duff and read "Harry Potter and the Cursed Child" - J.K. Rowling did her own Fan Fiction, and it's pretty darn good!

A Space to Grow

      I haven't written on this blog for a couple weeks, because I've been thinking very carefully about what I wanted to say.  A couple weeks ago, a series of painful, terrible events happened in Texas.*  Usually I say something about these kinds of killings.  But this time I didn't; this time I pretended nothing had happened.
      A couple people who know me personally asked about the absence of comment on my blog.  My explanation is simple: I got Tragedy Overload, and I got it bad.
      In psychology we talk about a phenomenon known as Emotional Flooding.  This is when a negative emotion - usually anxiety or anger, or both - becomes so intense that the brain just seems to jam.  This has probably happened to you during an important disagreement--or the person with whom you were arguing!  When someone is Flooded, they usually just stop talking.  They often avert their eyes, and if they do respond it tends to be monosyllabic, or just head gestures.
      This can be infuriating to the other party in the conversation.  We may accuse the Flooded individual of not caring, or giving up.  In fact, what science and technology are now able to reveal, the person is clamming up because they care a lot--too much, in fact.  The amount of stress hormone and associated neurotransmitters has sky-rocketed.  Their neurochemistry has reached a state where the brain cells can no longer effectively communicate logic, because the emotions are running too high.  When this happens, the Fight/Flight/Freeze center of the brain is triggered.  That shutting down is a form of Flight/Freeze.**

A simplistic visual, but accurate.  The Prefrontal Cortex is the rational, most useful problem-solving center of the brain.  (It's also the last to develop: the growth spurt starts around age 15 and wraps up ten years later.)  The Limbic System is fully developed when we're born, because our stress response is essential to survival.  So it can take over quickly and easily.
      Three days of horrific headlines, and I became Emotionally Flooded.  My brain just jammed.  There was just so much violence.  So much pointless, tragic stupidity!  I couldn't take it anymore.  I Froze, and then I Fled.  I fled by ignoring things.  I fled by pretending everything is fine, and there was nothing in the world more important than selecting french fries.
      I have the privilege of running away and ignoring.
      I caught myself.  I started talking to people about what happened.  More importantly, I listened.  I went to community meetings, and process groups.  And in thinking things through, I've come to two important conclusions:

1) These tragedies aren't going to stop happening.  Maybe the media will grow tired of reporting on them, or maybe the face of these tragedies will change again, but they won't stop.  And I don't want to be a part of the problem by ignoring them.  I'm a writer, and even if my audience is small, I want to do what I can to keep people thinking, and talking, and working to make things better.  Especially myself.

2) I do not want to do that in this blog.  I started Scribbles & Munch to be something fun and quirky in a stressful world.  Yes, racial injustice (and sexual injustice, and economic injustice) is rampant.  But I do not want it to define me, or my relationships.  I value the Black and Brown friends I have with whom I can discuss politics and power.  I also appreciate the laughter we share, and the recipes we swap, and the books we loan to one another.

      There needs to be room in my life for all of these things.  So, I am starting a second blog to focus on the issues of social injustice, and the actions we take - productive and destructive - that either perpetuate or attempt to correct those injustices.  I have already drafted a few entries, and I hope to have the blog up by the end of this week.
      I will still reference politics occasionally in Scribbled & Munch.  Even as a writer of fiction - or perhaps especially because I write fiction - I believe the values and messages relayed in my work are critical.
      To quote Tom Stoppard: "Words...can build bridges across incomprehension and chaos. [They are] sacred.  They deserve respect.  If you get the right ones in the right order, you can nudge the world a little."
So let's keep this conversation going.


*And then in France.  And then in Afghanistan.  And they just keep coming.

**The other option is Fight.  This can look like yelling, and saying things we regret.  It can turn to violence.  If that's something that happens to you or someone you care about, and that is NOT how you want to handle those situations, therapy can help.

Anime Review: High School of the Dead, Season One

      This post requires a little backstory.  Not of the anime, but of why Camela and I sat down and binge-watched all 12 episodes of the first season last Saturday, when it was a gorgeous sunny day in Seattle.

From left to right: me, Her Royal Snugglepants Hairy Squirrel-Murder, and Camela. I'm opening a bar of Theo's chocolate, having already demolished a bowl of home-made guacamole and an entire bag of lentil chips, and Camela is almost done with her first bag of tarro chips.  Because we take research seriously.
      I wanted to update my presentation materials for Greek Girl Con.  Camela and I, along with her editor Patricia, will be doing a panel on "Brainy Anime Babes Who Know More Science Than You." I already did this at Ohayocon earlier this year, and there were a few tweaks I wanted to make, starting with adding more Brainy Babes to my list!  So I appealed - and continue to appeal - to all the anime fans I know to suggest characters to add. And my new friend Sean suggested I watch High School Of The Dead.  Camela elected to join me for a binge viewing. So with a few breaks and a lot of snacks, we took the plunge.
      Let me first say that Sean now owes me a boba tea. Because the "brainy babe" in this show didn't actually do anything remotely brainy (besides scream "I'm a genius" several, several times) until the FINAL FREAKING EPISODE!  So does she qualify for the presentation, or not? Now I have to watch Season Two.  sigh
Although we knew from the beginning who the Brainy Babe would be, because she's wearing glasses. This IS anime, people. Embrace the predictability.

      There were some things about it I really liked. The art was good for TV show, with a lot of the most contemporary styles affecting face shape, but with some throw backs in hair.* Camela confirmed that it followed a classic survival horror story pattern in terms of plot pacing and development. We both liked the way the zombies were portrayed, with the quick "turn time," and consistent details in physicality and behavior.  So points for the horror stuff.
      But add a face-palm or two for the number of panty shots.  Seriously.  Don't get me wrong, I am an anime fan, and that means I am happy to embrace a few skirt flares.  I know enough about Japanese culture to chuckle at the timing, and be amused by the irony that staring at a girl's crotch is just fine, but kissing is pornographic.** All the same, the number of PS's quickly reached "gratuitous" level for me.  I have a system for this, but that's a different blog post.  At least the boys reacted appropriately: there was no judgement, and no assumptions of inherent invitation.  If that were the attitude at college parties then campuses would be much safer places.
      The REAL issue that both Camela and I had with the series was the violence against women.  Not from the zombies, from the protagonist.  In the very first episode, our "hero" goes to tell his ex-girlfriend they need to evacuate the school, and when she gives him lip for interrupting her class, he slaps her.
      No, don't try to justify it.  It's wrong.  Period.
There was a Mythbusters episode about the efficacy of a slap in reversing cognitive impairment.  I'm too lazy to look it up.  Just Google it.
      Scientific research has shown that a slap can help interrupt hysteria and increase cognitive functioning when the brain is impaired by cold or fatigue.  But that was not what was going on here.  This was a male who wanted to get a female to do what he wanted, and he employed violence.  And this happened again between the same two characters later in the season, and then again between the same male protagonist and another female.  And the worst part?  After their initial shock, the girls simpered and acted grateful for him taking charge.
      So let me say it again: THIS IS WRONG.  This is where fiction gets it wrong.  That's assault, plain and simple.  It is ineffective, unethical, and illegal, and all for good reasons.  That is not taking charge and being a man, that is letting base instinct over-rule better judgement, and being a primal asshole.  Stories have power, and as vendors of fiction, both Camela and believe we have a duty.  So I'm calling out the creators of High School Of The Dead.  Get your pre-pubescent wanna-be macho heads out of your daydream space (aka "ass").  If you want your character to be a hero, then you need to rethink his approach.
      I will be on the lookout for this when I watch Season Two.  As it stands, I'm not sure I can honestly recommend this series to anybody, for that reason.  I won't take it lightly.  Nobody should take it lightly.  Because that's exactly the problem.
      And you thought this was going to be a light, amusing piece about anime zombies.  Yeah...so did I.




*If you know what I mean by that, then you and I should go out for drinks, my fellow Otaku.

**H.S.O.T.D. is a fabulous example of this, by the way. There's boob jiggles and panty shots galore, and in one episode even full upper-body nudity (which I wasn't expecting), but no kissing.  There's music and soft lighting and camera pans whenever somebody goes in for a kiss.  Japan is fascinating.

Don't Try to Advance--You might put your foot in it.

      The one time I watched television during my time in Kauai last month was to watch the Oscars.  I was fully aware of the controversy surrounding the lack of ethnic minorities among the nominees, and I wanted to see if/how the Academy would respond.  I was not disappointed.  I thought this was one of the best, most intelligent, most socially conscientious Academy Awards I've ever seen.*
      It also brought to mind an issue I have struggled with as a writer for many years.  I happen to believe that popular media - TV, movies, music, and particularly books - are among the most effective tools for combating social prejudices.  Human beings judge what is "normal" and "acceptable" by our own experience, whether it's real or entertainment.  This is part of the reason the ethnic majority in any given country (but especially White Americans) have a hard time really empathizing with minorities: they assume their own experiences are typical, because they see it confirmed all over the place!  It's hard to understand your privilege if you're perpetually surrounded by it, just like it's hard for a swimming fish to understand that it's wet.

The real reason these goldfish have googly-eyes?  They discover this totally dry atmosphere up above them, and it BLOWS their MIND!  ...and two minutes later they discover this totally dry atmosphere up above them, and it BLOWS their MIND! ...and two minutes later they discover this totally dry atmosphere up above them, and it BLOWS their MIND! 
      I'm not judging or blaming here; this is just how the human brain works.  It takes a lot of continual effort to be aware of and combat this atmosphere of "normalcy."  Which is why it's important for people to be exposed to things that are different: different ethnicities, different religions, different cultures, different ideas, etc.  And the most palatable way to do this is through entertainment.
      Which brings me back to being a writer.  I want to have characters that are not the majority, aka: white, middle-class heterosexuals.  Writing women is easy for me because I'm a woman, and I have no trouble writing men.  I also feel pretty comfortable writing characters of all different sexual orientations.  With enough research I feel reasonably confident that I can write characters of different religious backgrounds.  What I don't feel comfortable writing is main characters of different ethnic/racial backgrounds.
      I want to, but then I feel like I shouldn't.  My brain runs around and around in circles like a dog chasing it's tail.  I'll break it down for you:

ONE HAND: I don't want to relegate all the ethnic minorities in my novels to being 'friends' or other minor characters. There is no reason this female protagonist need to be Caucasian.  I'll make her African American!

OTHER HAND: Really? And what do you - O Pasty Privileged One - know about being African American, and how that might affect this character's thoughts, experiences, and actions?

ONE HAND: Um...what I've read...and studied in Cultural Sensitivity Trainings...and seen in movies....

OTHER HAND: [gives withering look]

ONE HAND: Well, I've got a couple close friends who are African American, and we've talked about issues and experiences.

OTHER HAND: And you think a few episodes of lunch chit-chat qualifies you?

ONE HAND: Er...no.  That's pretty presumptive of me, thinking I can just wade in and write a convincing minority.  I don't want to be a Rudyard Kipling, full of good intent and unfortunate stereotypes.

OTHER HAND: That's what I thought.

ONE HAND: [defeated] Ok, I'll keep my main characters Caucasian.

OTHER HAND: [horrified] So all the ethnic minorities will be 'friends' and minor characters?
Aaaand around and around it goes.  This guy's had way more success than I have.
      Occasionally, some radical solutions come to mind, such as including extensive, self-deprecating disclaimers in the novel's forward. Or taking a few years of American Minority Studies courses at my local university.  They all end up smacking of intellectualization, when what I'm going for is human soul.  So here I am, baring my idiocy to the world (Hi, World!) in the hopes of getting some good advice from other writers.
      And in the meantime, I'll do what I should have done a long time ago: discuss my dilemma with my ethnic minority friends.  I think they're too nice to laugh at me...for more than an hour.



*Not to mention Lady Gaga and Vice-President Biden brought me to tears.  Ironically, the part I found the least sincere and engaging was when the President of the Academy - a black woman - came out on stage to address the accusations of "white washing" and pledging to do more.  She never said what they would do.  It came across as an empty gesture.  Weird.

My Fair (play) Lady

      Last month I saw a smashing performance of "My Fair Lady."  It had been years since I watched the movie with Audrey Hepburn (in my opinion, still the most beautiful Hollywood actress of all time), and I'd never seen a live performance of the whole musical.  The set design was great, the cast was brilliant, and the costumes were amazing--especially the hats!

Oh, the hats!!!!
      I had a great time, but there was some nagging little discomfort in the back of my mind.  Thanksgiving dinner occurred the very next day, however, and the copious amounts of turkey and other delicacies smothered said discomfort very well.  It wasn't until later when I found the playbill that I recollected the sensation, and began to ponder.
      My Fair Lady is a classic musical; a Broadway hit, rendered immortal by the film version, and the songs are frankly timeless.*  And the costumes.  Did I mention the hats?  Anyway, despite all this, it has never been one of my favorite musicals--but until this week I'd never stopped to wonder why.  Now, reflecting on the excellent stage production I'd just enjoyed, I finally put my finger on it.

WARNING: This really is a great musical, and if you've never seen it, you may want to stop here and enjoy it at least once without my spoilers and subsequent plot dissection.

      When you step back from the charm of the characters and the joy of the music, this is one really, really disturbing plot-line.  It basically tells the story of an impoverished young woman, neglected and exploited by her alcoholic father, who dares to attempt to break out of her under-privileged social caste only to become embroiled in an emotionally abusive relationship that disintegrates her social ties, shatters her identity, and seems to leave her chained to her abuser for life.  But with great dance numbers.
      So let's trace this back to it's roots.  The musical "My Fair Lady" is based on the play "Pygmalion" by George Bernard Shaw, which essentially tells the same story.  That play is based on the ancient Greek myth of the same name, briefly: a genius sculptor named Pygmalion scorns women and all concepts of romantic love, and decides to mock both by creating his "perfect woman" in the shape of a statue.  Displeased, Aphrodite makes him fall helplessly in love with his own creation.  For awhile he pretends, but eventually breaks down, begs the goddess's forgiveness, and asks for a real woman to love.  He returns to his workshop, kisses the statue farewell, only to find Aphrodite has taken pity on him and brings the statue to life as a woman named Galatea.  The End.
      Oddly enough, I've always loved that myth.  To me it's the story of a man recognizing his own folly and embracing humility.  But Pygmalion's reimagined character as Professor Higgins barely tastes even a crumb of humility in "My Fair Lady."**  If anything, it seems his concept of women as things - first as annoying things to be avoided, then a flawed thing to be changed, and finally as a thing that's preferable to have around after all - is reinforced by Eliza Doolittle's choice to return to him, even after the way he's treated her.  The way he focuses on her "flaws" and takes her assistance around his home for granted is impersonal at best, and the way he speaks to her is abusive.  Yes, abusive: let's call a spade a spade.
      The stage performance I saw last month attempted to address this issue. They coached the actors to use body language and inflection to create a sense of change in Higgins, and a sense of strength in Eliza.  They attempted to portray Higgins as having an epiphany of love in his final song, "I've Grown Accustom To Her Face," and also a feeling of humility in the tentative, penitent way he delivers his famous last line: "Eliza?  Where the devil are my slippers?"  But performance can only change the meaning of words so much.
Here's your bloody slippers, Henry.  Wear these for a few days, then we'll talk.
      This is what has been bothering me since the first time I saw this musical, which was about age 10.  I was a feminist at age 10, before I even knew what the word meant.  And I think that's because I have always had a deeply ingrained value of fair play.  Life isn't fair, the forces of Nature aren't fair, and Death is certainly never fair.  But human beings can choose to be fair in the ways they treat one another.  I am an advocate for women and minorities because society does not treat them fairly, and it should.  Henry Higgins treats Eliza Doolittle horribly unfairly, and it's a tragedy that she lets him.
      I want to re-write this musical.  Here's my version:

      Everything stays the same up until the night of the ball, with the exception of the Higgins house staff empathizing with Eliza instead of Henry.  When she leaves after his dismissive and impersonal treatment of her following the ball, the servants all quit.  The shock gives Henry a stroke.  The stroke causes him to lose the power of speech, making him even more ornery than before, and nobody will come and work for him.  On the verge of ruin, his mother comes to his aid (once more) by hiring Eliza - who has made good on her "threat" to become a vocal coach using Henry's own techniques - to teach him to speak again.  Eliza essentially takes control of his household, his finances, and his life, giving him a taste of his own medicine as she helps him re-learn how to talk.  And he REALLY learns humility then.


   My version makes this song seem waaaaay more ominous.  Which is frankly awesome. Anyway, I haven't decided whether they would end up together or not.  How would you end it?




*Proof: my husband, who had never seen the musical in any format, told me afterward that he recognized over half of the songs.

**I've neither read the script nor seen a performance of Shaw's play, so I cannot comment on his rendition.

Setting A Watchman Over Today's America

      This month is one of poignant anniversaries for the United States. Last week saw both the 50th anniversary of the Voting Rights Act, as well as the one year anniversary of the fatal shooting of Michael Brown.*  I can't imagine a better time to offer my two cents about Harper Lee's latest publication, "Go Set A Watchman."  I finished it about a week ago, and have been pondering it ever since.  I wanted to be sure I'd really given myself time to think before offering an opinion.
      This post is not intended to be a book review--I'll put that on Goodreads sometime over the weekend.  No, this post is intended to be an intellectual essay on the novel's social value.**  Also, this essay does assume you have read both "To Kill A Mockingbird" and "Go Set A Watchman," and is therefore redolent with spoilers.

      Since the first reviews, one of the most common lamentations regarding "Go Set A Watchman" has been the re-casting of Atticus Finch. Like Jean Louise herself, readers of "To Kill A Mockingbird" have been awestruck by the rare, brave acts of this White Southerner who was willing to stand up for the rights of a Black man. That is why, when Jean Louise discovers her father is now a member of the local White Supremacy movement, attempting to block federal imposition of civil rights, readers share in her outrage and grief.  But once past her initial shock (and a few glorious tirades later), Jean Louise is able to find a certain reconciliation with her father.  Also, this new Atticus Finch offers a very different, more subtle wisdom for his daughter. I believe that "Go Set A Watchman" is an invitation for readers to take lessons from both these heroes--lessons that are essential for the health of America, through the maturation of her citizens.  As 'Scout' grows into a woman who must confront the flaws of those she loves, so must Americans confront the flaws in our country, and the contradictions that continue to poison it's very core.
      As Jean Louise processes her utter disillusionment, she moves through three distinct phases, each demonstrating a specific kind of bravery.  First, there is her acceptance of what she has seen. Not only her father, but her sweetheart Hank are revealed as active racists through their support of the local White Citizen's Council.  At first her brain wishes to reject the evidence of her senses, and she is overwhelmed with childhood memories that seem to contradict this revelation.  But her integrity refuses to permit denial.  It is a rare reader indeed who cannot empathize with the pain of realizing our idols are not all that they seem, but even more rare is the individual who accepts this information at first blush.  We instinctually defend our central eidolons; the dearer to our hearts, the more entrenched our denial.
      Nowhere is this phenomenon more evident than in blind patriotism.  From our earliest classroom experiences, the Land of the Free and the Home of the Brave is glorified.  The sweet tales of brave settlers, daring revolutionaries, and noble idealists fill our heads.  We are taught that the concept of "All Men Are Created Equal" is the foundation of our country.  Of course, we grow older and learn about the many facets of racism that exist upon this jewel of a nation: slavery, near genocide, segregation, and systemic violence.  But how many Americans can do what Jean Louise did?  How many can absorb these truths as completely, rather than add them as mere footnotes to our mental construct?***  It takes a rare bravery to do this.
      Once we confront the truth for ourselves, it takes another kind of bravery to use the truth to confront others.  In America this can take a variety of shapes, from public protests to letters to the editor, from late night stand-up to getting out to vote.  (Whether or not this last one is "easy" is currently a matter of some debate.)  For Jean Louise, however, she was able to address her more personal disillusionment in a very personal - and passionate - way.  First she let into her intended.  Alas for him, Hank's defense regarding the stifling social pressure in closed-minded Maycomb County serves only to impresses Jean Louise with his cowardice.  But there is more than cowardice in his reaction: unjustly tainted with a "trashy" heritage, Hank was in such a perfect position to empathize with his Black neighbors, who are also limited by what boils down to nothing more than a coincidence of ancestry.  Yet instead of feeling drawn to their cause, he instead feels compelled to advance himself at their expense.  Hank's rhetoric reminded me of one of my favorite scenes from "Mississippi Burning," where Gene Hackman delivers a simple, yet eloquent explanation of one cause of racism.  Both show that in "accepting how things are," we submit to fear, and arrest our growth as human beings.
      In many ways, the defense offered by Atticus Finch upon confrontation is the reverse of his apprentice.  Atticus is not struggling to make changes for himself, but rather determined to prevent what he sees as harmful change being forced upon his community.  The impassioned dialogue between the attorney and his daughter include points of law, social development, and personal conviction.  Ultimately, both individuals are revealed as prejudiced beings.  Where Atticus sees an inferior race, however, Jean Louise is able to see the consequences of systemic oppression.  She understands this can and must change with time.  But much of her anger is personal, stemming from a sense of betrayal from the man she loved best, and here she receives no satisfaction: Atticus will not apologize, and will not admit to any wrong.  His calm and unwavering insistence that he loves his daughter makes Jean Louise feel defeated.
      The twist comes at the conclusion of the novel, when Jean Louise debriefs with her Uncle Jack. He reveals that he and Atticus have long known that she will someday come to differ with her father; if she were to live with only the values and convictions "borrowed" from him, then she would never truly be an adult.  This is Atticus's true heroism.  The deviation of values is the heart of every generational conflict, and the wedge in every bi-partisan debate.  But what Atticus knows as a man of politics is that law comes out of conflict, and justice is born of debate.  He is able to hold his convictions without denouncing the beliefs of others.  He is able to respect the need for his daughter to set her own watchman, and love her regardless of what she sees--even if it his own failings.  This is the true grace and wisdom of our forefathers, who were able to forge a nation based on compromise and the inevitability of change.  This is what the ugly face of modern politics must strive to become, if it is to truly serve the people.
      And it is this realization that provides for Jean Louise's final act of bravery: to absorb this value, and accept Atticus in kind.  She does not forget, and will not ignore, but she can adapt with love.  In so doing, she leaves herself open to her Uncle Jack's final suggestion that she move back to Maycomb County, and bring her outspoken liberalism with her.  Coming from an attitude of love and acceptance rather than scorn and belittlement, she has a much greater chance of being heard.  This is a truth that our nations greatest champions - from President Abraham Lincoln to Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. - understood very clearly, and we have all benefited from his acting upon that truth.
      If we as Americans are to further the causes of justice and peace, then we must learn to emulate the heroism of these characters.  We must be willing to see the flaws in our systems and admit the ugly truths of our country.  Armed with these truths, we must then take action, and not let those responsible off the hook.  Finally, we must find the grace to accept our differences.  When we say that the United States of America was founded upon the principle that all people are created equal, it does not mean that we have equal obligation to conform to somebody's idea of what is "right;" it means that our differences do not make us any lesser than one another.  Our constitution is not meant to force us into a narrow definition of citizenship, but to make a safe, respectful, bountiful home for the diverse.  If everyone's Watchman is her/his conscience, then let Harper Lee's latest book remind us not just to set, but to heed our Watchman as a country.
Full illustration credit: http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/jul/10/harper-lee-new-novel-first-chapter-extract-to-kill-a-mockingbird


*This month is also the 70th anniversary of the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.  My heart and my thoughts are with all of the victims - living and dead - of this tragic, world-changing event.  I hope for a day when the human race as a whole can no longer imagine inflicting such horrors upon other living creatures.

**Artistically, it has an entirely different value: this was a raw manuscript when it was published.  That means there was no editing to catch small errors such as inconsistent tense, or trim paragraphs, or smooth transitions between present day and past memories.  As a writer, I find it fascinating to read this novel and wonder what the editor saw in it that she continued to work with Harper Lee in creating a novel that would become famous around the world.  If the editor had read only the first ten pages (as many agents and editors do), I think she would have trashed it.

***Ironically, since many of these historical facts appear as little more than footnotes in the history lessons taught in our public schools.

Harper Lee's Continuing Legacy

      On Tuesday, I went to my favorite area bookstore and picked up a couple hardcovers, as follows:

A seriously awesome haul
      I pre-ordered Armada about a month ago, in anticipation of the author coming to Columbus for a reading next week.  I'm currently six chapters in, but I'll write more about the book (and the signing) next week.
      Go Set A Watchman I had not pre-ordered.  In fact, until the day it was released, I hadn't made up my mind as to whether or not I would read it at all, much less buy the book.  When I first heard that a second novel by Harper Lee was coming out, my initial reaction was literary ecstasy.  Then I heard about the controversy regarding the publication, and I realized I needed to give myself some time to calm the heck down and seriously consider what I wanted to support, and why. 
      If you haven't been following the news around this book, I'll give you a very quick and dirty summary.  Harper Lee has only ever published one novel: To Kill A Mockingbird.  Widely considered one of the greatest examples of 20th century American literature, it won a Pulitzer Prize, and was also banned in dozens if not hundreds of school districts across the U.S.*  But it's not what she originally wrote.  As I understand it, in the 1950's Harper Lee left her small hometown in Alabama to go work in New York.  After a few years of a successful career up north, she went back to be with her family.  The racism she encountered mortified her to her core. 
     In response to this experience, she wrote a book about her family and childhood, with the working title of Go Set A Watchman.  In 1957 she sent the manuscript to J.B. Lippincott Publishing Company, where it fell on the desk of editor Tay Hohoff.  The editor felt the manuscript was powerful, but lacked the clear development and arch of a novel.  She worked with Harper Lee to create the kind of traditional novel layout that readers would find more appealing, and in 1960 To Kill A Mockingbird was published.
Despite the author's portrayal of Alabama, she was nevertheless honored by many in her home state.
      Fast forward to 2014, when a copy of the original manuscript was purportedly discovered by the elderly Harper Lee's attorney.  It was decided that the time was ripe to publish Go Set A Watchman in it's original form.  Whether or not Harper Lee is truly cognizant/permissive of this publication has been a matter of severe debate, as many claim she suffers dementia.  This controversy is compounded by the - and I'm just going to be blunt here - shit-ton of money her lawyers and publishers stand to make from this, and the relative pittance the author will receive.  Tay Hohoff has been dead for many years and could not speak to any agreements made between her and the author 65 years ago.  For this reason, many people have sworn not to read the book.
      But another reason many are declining to read this new publication is because of how strongly it varies from To Kill A Mockingbird.  Part of the first book's genius (and its divisiveness) was its unadorned depiction of entrenched racism in the deep south of the 1930's.  The hero of this book - the narrator's father, attorney Atticus Finch - was a brave example of how one individual can overcome social pressure and stand up for what is right.  He became a fictional icon of manliness, and some would argue that playing his role made Gregory Peck's career.  
      What Go Set A Watchman reveals is that, in her original manuscript, Harper Lee's father was portrayed as first-class bigot.
      Talk about knocking an idol of the pedestal.  People are heart-broken, crying out that this ruins the original classic, encouraging others not to tarnish Atticus Finch's fictional integrity with this rudely variation.  There are some people I love and respect who are giving very serious thought as to whether or not they want to mar their understanding of this character by reading Go Set A Watchman.  And I really do get it--it would be a bit like finding out that The Doctor is a homophone who supports banning same-sex marriage.**  But I fully intend to read this book, and I believe the author would want me to.  Here's why:
      In 1957, pre-Civil Rights Act America, the country was in desperate need of a wake-up call.  It needed a mirror held brutally in front of its face, to show citizens of the blind, horrific truth of racial prejudice, which had grown so deep in our culture that it eclipsed our reason and our morals.  Today, our country needs that mirror once more.  Not to show us how ugly racism is, but to prove to us that it is still there.  Maybe not as obviously as 65 years ago, but nevertheless present, and relentlessly influential.  With the renewed focus on the bias of our legal system (at all levels), and the unfathomable acceptance of hate symbols, Go Set A Watchman is as timely as ever.  We do need to revisit our heroes.  We do need to take a good whiff of our sacred cows and see whether that's prime beef or pink slime.***  
      I think that if we could time-travel the Harper Lee of 1957 to 2015, she would fold her arms, look us in the eye, and say, "Fuck the money--I can't take it with me, and neither can they.  It's the story that endures."  She would be right--and hers is a story I mean to read.


      


*To my knowledge, it is recommended - if not required - reading in every other school district.

**Which he obvious doesn't, didn't, and won't.

***Not 100% sure if that particular metaphor cocktail comes out Ok, but I'm leaving it in there!

Powered by Blogger.